This is a documentary about a high school student government election. Most of the writeups talk about how it parallels the broader electoral situation in US. That's true, but I don't think that's the reason to see the movie. There's no high drama here along the lines of the drama most likely to come to mind - Election. It's a simple movie, but very entertaining and manages to be so without exploiting any of the subjects. It's good and only available in a limited run at the Northwest Film Forum so make some time this week or mark it on your "to rent" list.The film follows an election for Student Union President/Vice-president at Stuyvesant High School in Manhattan. For those not familiar it's a highly selective public school where admission is granted only to the top few percent of scorers in an admission test. So this is not a dumb group of kids. At times it's easy to forget that since the various tickets at first seem break down along familiar lines to anyone who's seen a teen comedy. But it's the rare teen film where the "cheerleader" character mentions in passing some advice her Robotics teacher gave her. It's a nice change.
The group for all their intelligence, often comes across as goofy as any other group of teenagers. The trailer below starts off with one of the funniest aspects of the film. An interview with the presidential candidate talking about something or other with the vice-presidential candidate rolling her eyes given his extended ramblings. That dynamic repeats itself quite a lot, most of the best aspects come from keeping your gaze on the "bottom" of each ticket. The film doesn't go into it in depth, but one gets the sense that the VP candidates are friends (platonic or otherwise) that got roped into something vs. the presidentials who appear to be more ego driven. The story follows all four campaigns, but dives deepest into the two that make it past the primary. You get the political angle of course but also a bit of real life characters that you may recognize not just from the traditional teen stereotype films but also from the quirkier ones such as Rushmore or Election (with a bit of Ferris Bueller thrown in) - for example the one who sets up his lounge in a school hallway complete with chairs and a roped off discussion section.
There are definitely analogies a'plenty to the true presidential elections. The candidates at Stuyvesant produce campaign literature, shake hands, engage in televised debates, seek newspaper endorsements, etc. Perhaps most notably they all factor in racial politics to some extent, if only commenting that the ticket without an Asian member is at a severe disadvantage. We watch the school newspaper staff debate whether to just present the candidate's platforms or to call things out that aren't correct/don't make sense. For me the most interesting political line in the film comes from the staff member who complains that letting the candidates speak without any analysis is akin to just publishing all of their campaign literature and a therefore adds no value. There's a passing subtext of the Stuy student body being apathetic - the percent that vote is clearly fairly low. Though it seems to me that being apathetic about your high school election is perhaps more rational than not voting for the president of the country.
The true pleasure for me came from just watching the students go through the experience. At times absolutely laugh out loud funny (I hadn't laughed until I cried in a while at the movies) other times sad. I don't think I picked up any big new truths about the universe. But I got to watch a subculture that's probably similar and different to most high schools in the country. I particularly liked the filmmaker's approach which really treated all the topics softly letting you take what you wanted from the film vs. hitting you over the head with a specific conclusion. A personal observation - it was nice to see a school of kids that while perhaps over-driven in studies comes across as more accepting of quirks and differences than those we normally see in other "high school" films. I went to a selective public HS in NYC (though not Stuy) amongst a not entirely dissimilar bunch of kids and this was closer to my experience than something like that depicted in American Teen (another good film) earlier in the year.









